LEARN > choose an ira
Partnership Disclosure
We might be compensated by one of our IRA partners for an account you open through our platform. This helps us keep the rollover service free, but it never impacts the fees you’ll pay on your new account. We only win if you do, and our job is to help you simplify your retirement accounts. We also help people who already have an IRA account even though we might receive no compensation in these situations—because it’s just the right thing to do!

Betterment IRA vs TD Essentials IRA

Updated on May 29, 2024

Learn about our Editorial Process

Betterment offers an automated IRA as the largest independent online financial advisor, and pioneered "set-it-and-forget-it" portfolios for a low-fee.

TD Ameritrade offers an automated IRA with no management fee and a wide range of portfolio options.

Find & move your old 401(k)s into your new IRA
Provider
Betterment
Automated IRA
TD Ameritrade
Automated IRA
Fees
Betterment
$4/month for balances under $20,000, and 0.25% annual fee for balances over $20,000. You can also choose to upgrade to Betterment's premium plan with a $100,000 minimum balance which adds 0.15% to the management fee.
TD Ameritrade
0%
What they invest in
Betterment
Betterment creates a diversified portfolio of ETFs (Exchange-traded funds) based on your risk tolerance and investment goals.
TD Ameritrade
All digital advisors create a diversified portfolio of ETFs (Exchange-traded funds) based on your risk tolerance and preferences
Limitations
Betterment
Access to human financial advisors is only available through their Premium plan, or through purchase of an advice package for the Digital plan.
TD Ameritrade
Schwab's automated IRA has a $5,000 account minimum which is a little higher than other providers, but comes with 24/7 human support.
Human advisor available?
Betterment
Yes - you can buy a consultation ($299) or pay a higher annual fee (0.40%) for unlimited access on an ongoing basis.
TD Ameritrade
Yes, the Schwab's Premium Intelligent Portfolios offering; requires $25,000 minimum balance and costs $30 a month in addition to a $300 one time planning fee.
Account minimums
Betterment
$10 to get started investing, $0 minimum account balance
TD Ameritrade
5000
Ease of use
Betterment
Star filledStar filledStar filledStar filledStar filled
5 stars
TD Ameritrade
Star filledStar filledStar filled
3 stars stars
Rollover

Fund a Betterment IRA with a 401(k) rollover

Get Started

Fund a TD Ameritrade IRA with a 401(k) rollover

Get Started
COMPARE

Compare Betterment IRA to another IRA product

Betterment IRA vs Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA

Compare

Betterment IRA vs Merrill Guided Investing IRA

Compare

Betterment IRA vs TD Essentials IRA

Compare
COMPARE

Compare TD Essentials Automated IRA to another IRA product

Find & move your old 401(k)s into your new IRA